Find a TenderAwarded
Published 4 Aug 2023, 11:40 BST

Official UK procurement notice

Provision of External Audit and Corporation Tax Compliance for Council Companies

Official notice

Authority: The City of Edinburgh Council (Local council)

ServicesOpen procedure
Published estimate£540,000exc. VAT · 1 value update23.4% below published estimate
Submissions closed 9 Oct 2023awarded 27 Nov 2023
Awarded to Azets Holdings Limited

What is being bought

Published requirement description

The City of Edinburgh Council requires a Service Provider to undertake annual external audit, group accounts consolidations, group tax efficiency and associated Corporation Tax calculations (and lodging of returns) for a number of Council companies.

There may be occasions where ad-hoc specialist and advisory services are required from the Service Provider in relation to the Council's companies.

  • Recurrence: If the full contract period is undertaken, this requirement shall likely be re-tendered in mid 2029

CPV: Accounting and auditing services · Accounting review services · Accounting services · Accounting, auditing and fiscal services · Auditing services · Financial auditing services · Statutory audit services · Tax consultancy services · Tax-return preparation services

The lotProcurement structure

single lot · no lot value published
Lot #1AwardedRenewal
Delivery: Scotland
Extensions: There may be occasions where ad-hoc specialist and advisory services are required from the Service Provider in relation to the Council's companies. · The Council wishes to hold the option to extend for up to a further 24 months, undertaken at the sole discretion of the Council.Variant bids: not allowed

What it takes to win
i

How this buyer will score bids.

The evaluation criteria and weights exactly as published on the notice, grouped by family (price, quality, social value and so on).

Evaluation split and conditions of participation as published; the tender pack may add more
How bids were scored
Quality: 30%Price: 70%
Published award criteria (2)
  • Quality: 30
  • Price: 70
Conditions of participation4
  • Suitability

    Part IV: Selection Criteria - A: Professional & Trade Registers - Question 4A.1 and 4A.2

    The specification states the appointed Supplier must ensure their organisation and, where applicable, staff members are registered as an auditor with a relevant professional body. Please use the questions 4A.1 and 4A.2 to confirm and provide details of compliance with this criteria.

    Where a Tenderer’s response is of a less than the acceptable standard, the Council may exclude the Tenderer from the competition or may apply discretion seeking supporting evidence to determine the Tenderer’s suitability to proceed in the competition.

  • Economic & financial standing

    Part IV: Selection criteria - B: Economic and financial standing – Question 4B.1 - Tenderers are required to have a minimum “general” annual turnover of 180,000 GBP for the last two financial years. Where a Tenderer does not have an annual turnover of this value, the Council may exclude the Tenderer from the competition or may apply discretion seeking supporting evidence to determine the Tenderer’s suitability to proceed in the competition.

    Part IV: Selection criteria - B: Economic and financial standing – Question 4B.4 - Tenderers will be required provide the following information in response to 4B.4:

    • Current ratio for Current Year: 1.10
    • Current ratio for Prior Year: 1.10

    The formula for calculating a Tenderer’s current ratio is current assets divided by current liabilities. The acceptable range for each financial ratio is greater than 1.10. Where a Tenderer’s current ratio is less than the acceptable value, the Council may exclude the Tenderer from the competition or may apply discretion seeking supporting evidence to determine the Tenderer’s suitability to proceed in the competition.

    Part IV: Selection criteria - B: Economic and financial standing – Question 4B.5 - Tenderers are required to hold, or commit to obtaining prior to the commencement of any subsequently awarded contract, the types and levels of insurance indicated below:

    • Employers (Compulsory) Liability Insurance - 5m GBP
    • Professional Indemnity Insurance - 5m GBP
  • Technical & professional ability

    Part IV: Selection criteria – C: Prompt Payment – Question 4C.4 – It is a mandatory requirement of this Contract that a prompt payment clause is present in all Contracts used in the delivery of the requirements. This ensures payment of sub-contractors at all stages of the supply chain within 30 days and includes an obligation to provide a point of contact for sub-contractors to refer to in the case of payment difficulties. This will require active monitoring of payment performance as well as the provision of evidence and reports to the Council on request or as contractually scheduled. Bidders should confirm that this condition will be met within the response to this question. Please note that tenderers who fail to answer “Yes” to this question may not have their tender considered further or proceed to the Price/Quality ratio calculation.

    Part IV: Selection criteria – C: Living Wage Payment – Question 4C.4 – Tenderers are asked to confirm that they will pay staff that are involved in the delivery of the contract (including any agency or sub-contractor staff directly involved in the delivery of the contract), at least the real Living Wage. Bidders should confirm that this condition will be met within the response to this question. Please note that tenderers who fail to answer “Yes” to this question may not have their tender considered further or proceed to the Price/Quality ratio calculation.

    Part IV: Selection criteria - C: Environmental Management Measures – Question 4C.7 – B…

  • Technical & professional ability

    Section 1212 of the Companies Act 2006

    An individual or firm is eligible for appointment as a statutory auditor if the individual or firm—

    a) is a member of a recognised supervisory body, and

    b) is eligible for appointment under the rules of that body.

Staff
Names and qualifications of delivery staff must be submitted
What this means for your bid
  • Price carries 70 of 100 points: a 10% discount moves about 7 points. This one is won on the number: sharpen the price before polishing the prose.

Price arithmetic assumes straight proportional scoring; the tender pack may use another formula.

Procedure terms & legal framework

From the official record · publisher note attached
Procedure method
Open procedure
Legal basis
CELEX · 32014L0024 Public Contracts Regulations 2015 (Directive 2014/24/EU)
Procurement category
Services
Notice status
Awarded
Procurement threshold
Unspecified in notice
Regulatory regime
Standard
Commercial structure
Stand-alone contract (no framework)
Competition type
Competitive procedure
GPA / WTO covered
Yes (GPA)
Recurring procurement
Yes · If the full contract period is undertaken, this requirement shall likely be re-tendered in mid 2029
First published
4 Aug 2023, 11:40 BST
Last source update
24 Jan 2024, 16:55 GMT
Award evaluation window
9 Oct 2023 – …
Authority reference
CT2999
FTS notice number
2024/S 000-002483
Classification (CPV)
Accounting and auditing servicesAccounting review servicesAccounting servicesAccounting, auditing and fiscal servicesAuditing servicesFinancial auditing servicesStatutory audit servicesTax consultancy servicesTax-return preparation services
Delivery area
Scotland (UKM75)
Official registry OCID
ocds-h6vhtk-03ed0a Find a Tender
Contract terms
Electronic trading
e-invoicing allowed · electronic ordering · electronic payment
Review and risk notes
Review procedure

A tenderer that suffers loss as a result of a breach of duty under the Public Contracts (Scotland) Regulations 2015 may bring proceedings in the Sheriff Court or the Court of Session. Post contract award the Sheriff Court or the Court of Session may (1) award damages provided proceedings are brought within 3 months from the date when the grounds for the bringing of the proceedings first arose (2) be entitled to issue an ineffectiveness order or impose a financial penalty on the Council. A claim for an ineffectiveness order must be made within 30 days of the Contract Award Notice being published in the FTS or within 30 days of the date those who expressed an interest in or otherwise bid for the contract were informed of the conclusion of the contract or in any other case within 6 months from the date on which the contract was entered into.

Publisher note: It is a mandatory requirement of this Contract that a prompt payment clause is present in all Contracts used in the delivery of the requirements. This ensures payment of sub-contractors at all stages of the supply chain within 30 days and includes an obligation to provide a point of contact for sub-contractors to refer to in the case of payment difficulties. This will require active monitoring of payment performance as well as the provision of evidence and reports to the Council on request or as contractually scheduled. (SC Ref:754285)

How it was run

Official notice
Run through: Public Contracts Scotland · Who buys & how to bid on PCS
Supplier login requiredLanguage: EN
Access & registration note: Free single registration for Scotland; PCS-Tender (Jaggaer) for full bidding
Submission deadline
9 Oct 2023, 12:00 BST
Submission channel
{"electronicSubmission"}
Accepted languages
en
Bid validity
3600 days from the deadline
Bids opened
9 Oct 2023, 12:00 BST
Detailed submission instructions & authority contactsFrom official release

Timeline

2 Oct 2023 → 24 Jan 2024 · 4 dates
  1. Next notice expected
    2 Oct 2023, 00:00 BST
  2. Submission deadline
    9 Oct 2023, 12:00 BST
  3. Bids opened
    9 Oct 2023, 12:00 BST
  4. Notice published
    24 Jan 2024, 16:55 GMT

Notice history

5 events · 3 releases on Find a Tender · since 8 Sept 2023
  1. Published value updated to £540,000
    8 Sept 2023, 13:59 BST
    was £660,000
  2. Status changed to active
    8 Sept 2023, 13:59 BST
  3. Procurement method changed
    8 Sept 2023, 13:59 BST
  4. Deadline published: 9 Oct 2023, 12:00 BST
    8 Sept 2023, 13:59 BST
  5. Status changed to complete
    24 Jan 2024, 16:55 GMT

Commercial outcome & contract awards

Published awards, contracts and bid statistics, not a forecast
Awards 1
Awarded value £413,7331 contract exc. VAT
Bids received 1
Contracts signed 1latest 27 Nov 2023
Awarded toValueDateStatus
Azets Holdings Limited£413,733 †—Awarded

Contracts

Bid statistics published by the authority

BidsSMEVCSEValid bid range
1bids · 1 electronic · 1 from abroad0——

Contracting authority & participating public bodies

The City of Edinburgh Council

Contracting authorityLocal CouncilRegional or local authorityGeneral public services Waverley Court, 4 East Market Street, Edinburgh, Scotland, EH8 8BGContact name, email Published organisation website ↗

Dispute resolution & review bodies

  • Sheriff CourtReview body Edinburgh

Bidders & participating suppliers

1 commercial party on the notice
  • Azets Holdings LimitedAwarded supplier 2nd Floor Regis House, 45 King William Street, London, London, EC4R 9ANContact phone

Official documents & specifications

Official links; attachments are not copied

No document links were published on the notice.